• Floyd Smith 1970-71
• Gerry Meehan 1971-74
• Jim Schoenfeld 1974-77
• Danny Gare 1977-82
• Gilbert Perreault 1982-87
• Lindy Ruff 1987-89
• Mike Foligno 1989-91
• Mike Ramsey 1991-92
• Pat LaFonatine 1992-97
• Alexander Mogilny 11/93 – 4/29/94
• Michael Peca 1997-2000
• Stu Barnes 2001-03
• Miroslav Satan 10/03
• Chris Drury 11/03
• James Patrick 12/03
• J.P. Dumont 1/04
• Daniel Briere 2/04-2007
• Chris Drury 3/04 – 2007
• Jochen Hecht 10/07, 1/08
• Toni Lydman 11/07
• Jaroslav Spacek 12/07
• Jason Pominville 3/08-4/08
• Craig Rivet 10/08 – 2/11

Currently the C is vacant. Rivet was waived on 2/26/11 and claimed by Columbus Blue Jackets